Conradus de Soltau - Principium libri IV - THESIS Digital Text Library
Library
Dionysius de Montina - Liber in quatuor Sententiarum
Alphonsus Toletanus Vargas - Commentary
Conradus de Soltau - Quaestiones super quattuor libros Sententiarum Petri Lombardi
Test Author 1 - Test Title 1
Query
Text Query
XPath Query
Login
Conradus de Soltau - Quaestiones super quattuor libros Sententiarum Petri Lombardi
Principium libri IV
xml
Conradus de Soltau - Principium libri IV [cdss4s-l4q1.xml]
text
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> <!-- Collexy Critical Edition Collation (c) Mihai Maga --> <!DOCTYPE TEI PUBLIC "-//TEI P5//DTD Main Document Type//EN" "http://www.tei-c.org/release/xml/tei/schema/dtd//tei.dtd"> <TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns:xi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XInclude"> <teiHeader> <fileDesc xml:id="cdss4s-l4q1" n="402"> <titleStmt> <title>Principium libri IV</title> <author>Conradus de Soltau</author> </titleStmt> <publicationStmt> <distributor>Mihai Maga</distributor> </publicationStmt> <seriesStmt> <title>Quaestiones super quattuor libros Sententiarum Petri Lombardi</title> </seriesStmt> <sourceDesc> <listWit> <!-- <witness xml:id="B1" n="04">Berlin, Staatsbibliothek, lat. fol. 218</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="G1" n="09">Greifswald, Geistliches Ministerium, VII.E.77</witness>--> <witness xml:id="K1" n="10">Kraków, Biblioteka Jagiellońska, cod. 457</witness> <witness xml:id="Ma1" n="18">Mainz, Stadtbibliothek, Hs I 16</witness> <!-- <witness xml:id="M1" n="19">München, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 7010</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="M4" n="22">München, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 14219</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="M6" n="24">München, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 18359</witness>--> <witness xml:id="M9" n="27">München, Universitätsbibliothek, 2° 65</witness> <!-- <witness xml:id="Ox1" n="28">Oxford, Bodleian Library, Hamilton 23</witness>--> <witness xml:id="Ox2" n="29">Oxford, Bodleian Library, Hamilton 33</witness> <witness xml:id="Pr1" n="30">Praha, Národní knihovna České republiky, I.D.23</witness> <!-- <witness xml:id="S1" n="35">Stuttgart, Landesbibliothek, Theol. fol. 118</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="S2" n="36">Stuttgart, Württembergische Landesbibliothek, HB III 53</witness>--> <witness xml:id="T1" n="37">Toruń, Biblioteka Uniwersytecka, Rps 51/III</witness> <witness xml:id="U1" n="39">Uppsala, Universitetsbibliotek, C 166</witness> <!-- <witness xml:id="W3" n="43">Wien, Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, Cod. 4578</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="W4" n="44">Wien, Österreichische Nationalbibliothek, Cod. 4709</witness>--> <witness xml:id="W5" n="45">Wien, Dominikanerkloster, Cod. Dominicanorum Vindob. 153 (123)</witness> <witness xml:id="Wo1" n="46">Wolfenbüttel, Herzog August Bibliothek, Cod. Guelf. 230 Helmst.</witness> <!-- <witness xml:id="Wr1" n="49">Wrocław, Biblioteka Uniwersytecka, I F 176</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="Wr2" n="50">Wrocław, Biblioteka Uniwersytecka, I F 189</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="Wr3" n="51">Wrocław, Biblioteka Uniwersytecka, I F 190</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="Wr4" n="52">Wrocław, Biblioteka Uniwersytecka, I F 193</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="Wr5" n="53">Wrocław, Biblioteka Uniwersytecka, I F 315</witness>--> <!-- <witness xml:id="Wr8" n="56">Wrocław, Biblioteka Ossolineum, 385/II</witness>--> <witness xml:id="eM" n="102">ed. Mihai Maga</witness> </listWit> <listBibl xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xml:id="listBibl"> <bibl xml:id="b-B-Gen"> <author key="B" rend="hidden">Biblia</author> <title key="Gen">Gen.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-B-Is"> <author key="B" rend="hidden">Biblia</author> <title key="Is">Is.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-B-Matth"> <author key="B" rend="hidden">Biblia</author> <title key="Matth">Matth.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-B-ICor"> <author key="B" rend="hidden">Biblia</author> <title key="ICor">I Cor.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Arist-DeInterpr"> <author key="Arist">Arist.</author> <title key="DeInterpr">De interpr.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Arist-AnalPoster"> <author key="Arist">Arist.</author> <title key="AnalPoster">Anal. poster.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Arist-DeAn"> <author key="Arist">Arist.</author> <title key="DeAn">De anima</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Arist-EthNic"> <author key="Arist">Arist.</author> <title key="EthNic">Eth. Nic.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-X-AuctArist"> <title key="AuctArist">Auctoritates Arist.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Aug-DeTrin"> <author key="Aug">Augustinus</author> <title key="DeTrin">De Trinitate</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Aug-DeLibArb"> <author key="Aug">Augustinus</author> <title key="DeLibArb">De libero arbitrio</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Aug-DePraedestSanct"> <author key="Aug">Augustinus</author> <title key="DePraedestSanct">De praedestinatione sanctorum</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Aug-Serm168"> <author key="Aug">Augustinus</author> <title key="Serm168">Sermo 168</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-PLomb-Sent"> <author key="PLomb">Petr. Lombard.</author> <title key="Sent">Sent.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-HugoSV-DeSacram"> <author key="HugoSV">Hugo de S. Victore</author> <title key="DeSacram">De sacramentis</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-Bonav-Sent"> <author key="Bonav">Bonaventura</author> <title key="Sent">Super Sent.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-HenrGand-Quodl15"> <author key="HenrGand">Henricus de Gandavo</author> <title key="Quodl15">Quodlibet XV</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-ThArg-Sent"> <author key="ThArg">Th. de Argentina</author> <title key="Sent">Super Sent.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-MensoBeckh-Sent"> <author key="MensoBeckh">Menso de Beckhusen</author> <title key="Sent">Super Sent.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-NicGubin-Sent"> <author key="NicGubin">Nicolaus de Gubin</author> <title key="Sent">Super Sent.</title> </bibl> <bibl xml:id="b-ConrSoltau-Sent"> <author key="ConrSoltau">Conradus de Soltau</author> <title key="Sent">Super Sent.</title> </bibl> </listBibl> </sourceDesc> </fileDesc> <encodingDesc> <variantEncoding method="parallel-segmentation" location="internal"/> </encodingDesc> </teiHeader> <text> <body> <p rend="TitleCaps"> <locus target="#K1" from="338a" rend="block"/> <locus target="#Ma1" from="152ra" rend="block"/> <locus target="#M9" from="98ra" rend="block"/> <locus target="#Ox2" from="107ra" rend="block"/> <locus target="#Pr1" from="131va" rend="block"/> <locus target="#T1" from="125va" rend="block"/> <locus target="#U1" from="126vb" rend="block"/> <locus target="#W5" from="92rb" rend="block"/> <locus target="#Wo1" from="391vb" rend="block"/> < Quaestio I > </p> <p> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">sequitur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">quaeritur</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #T1">quaestio</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1 #T1 #U1 #W5">circa</rdg> <witDetail wit="#K1 #Pr1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#T1">distinctionem</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#T1">primam</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5">principium</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1 #U1">quartum</rdg> <rdg wit="#T1">libri</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5">quarti</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Pr1">librum</rdg> <rdg wit="#T1">quarti</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5">libri</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1 #T1 #U1 #W5">Sententiarum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9 #U1 #W5">quaeritur</rdg> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Distinctio prima</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">utrum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">etc</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Utrum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">an</rdg> <witDetail wit="#M9 #U1 #W5" type="iter"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Prima</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>divina</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #U1 #W5" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>sacramenta</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #U1 #W5" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>semper</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>fuerint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">fuerunt</rdg> </app> homini <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">semper</rdg> </app> necessaria. <app> <lem>Quod</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Probatio</witDetail> </app> sic, <app> <lem>arguitur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app>: quia pro quocumque statu homo <app> <lem>indiguit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">indiguerit</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="ac">indiguisset</witDetail> </app> gratia pro eodem <app> <lem>fuerunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fuerint</rdg> <rdg wit="#Pr1">fuerant</rdg> </app> sibi sacramenta necessaria cum ipsa sint per <app> <lem>quae</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc"/> </app> nobis <locus target="#K1" from="338b"/> <app> <lem>confertur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">gratia</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>gratia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">confertur</rdg> </app>. Sed homo numquam fuit <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">sic</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg"/> </app> in statu quin <app> <lem>indiguerit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">indiguit</rdg> </app> gratia ad beatitudinem consequendam, igitur quaestio vera. <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1 #T1 #W5">assumptum</rdg> <witDetail wit="#T1 #W5" type="exp"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">patet</rdg> <rdg wit="#T1 #W5">probatur</rdg> <witDetail wit="#T1 #W5" type="exp"/> </app> <app> <lem>Oppositum</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Oppositum</witDetail> </app> arguitur <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>: in statu innocentiae, divina sacramenta non fuerunt <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">semper</rdg> </app> <locus target="#U1" from="127ra"/> homini necessaria, igitur quaestio falsa. Assumptum probatur: quia, ut dicit venerabilis Hugo, ‘<ref target="#snx001" type="source" n="1"/>sacramenta <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #U1 #Wo1">sunt</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Wo1" from="392ra"/> vasa medicinae<note xml:id="snx001" type="source" source="#b-HugoSV-DeSacram" subtype="cf" n="1">lib. 1, p. 9, cap. 4</note>’; sed in statu innocentiae homo per iustitiam <app> <lem>originalem</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">origenalem</rdg> </app> fuit perfecte <app> <lem>sanus</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="del">s</witDetail> </app>, igitur vasa medicinae <app> <lem>tunc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2"/> </app> non <app> <lem>erant</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fuerunt</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">tunc</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg"/> </app> necessaria, <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">per consequens</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">igitur</witDetail> </app> nec sacramenta. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Praemissa</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Materia conclusionis</witDetail> </app> protestatione, <label type="structure">Divisio</label> circa solutionem huius quaestionis volo <app> <lem>pertractare</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">tractare</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #M9">illa</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1">et quem vel minus principaliter</rdg> </app> tria. <app> <lem>Primo</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">primorum</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">1</witDetail> </app>, sacramentorum institutionem. <app> <lem>Secundo</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">2</witDetail> </app>, ipsorum significationem. <app> <lem>Tertio</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">3</witDetail> </app>, propositam quaestionem. Quibus expeditis, descendam ad aliquas materias in <ref target="#snx002" type="source" n="2"/>prioribus <app> <lem>meis</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="supl"/> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="ac">magis</witDetail> </app> principiis<note xml:id="snx002" type="source" source="#b-ConrSoltau-Sent" subtype="cf" n="2">lib. 2, pr., q. 1, art. 1, co. 1-3; art. 2, co. 1; lib. 3, pr., q. 1, art. 1, co. 1</note> <app> <lem>tractatas</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">positas</rdg> </app>, in quibus replicabo contra dominos et magistros mecum concurrentes, qui dignati <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sint</rdg> </app> contra dicta mea opponere, et circa ipsa confere <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">etc</rdg> </app>. </p> <p rend="Title"> < Articulus I > </p> <p> <app> <lem>Quantum</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Primus articulus</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Conclusio prima</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="mg">Conclusio una primi articuli</witDetail> </app> ad primum, pono <app> <lem>istam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Ox2">illam</rdg> </app> conclusionem, <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <label type="structure">Concl. 1</label> institutio sacramentorum Deum decuit et nobis expediens <app> <lem>fuit</lem> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="del">l.</witDetail> </app>. Hanc conclusionem <app> <lem>declarat</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">declaret</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Bonaventura</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">Bonaventis</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">sicut</rdg> </app>: “<ref target="#snx003" type="source" n="3"/>Decuit quippe Dei misericordiam, <locus target="#T1" from="125vb"/> iustitiam <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Pr1">vel</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Ma1" from="152rb"/> sapientiam, in quibus consideratur omnis via <app> <lem>Domini</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">Deum</rdg> </app>. Decuit”, <app> <lem>inquam</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">inquantum</witDetail> </app>, “Dei misericordiam, quia homo male gratiam <app> <lem>servabat</lem> <witDetail wit="#Wo1" type="ac">conservabat</witDetail> </app> propter voluntatis <app> <lem>vertibilitatem</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">fertilitatem</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">utilitatem</rdg> </app>; ideo Deus instituit sacramenta, <app> <lem>ad</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #T1">atque</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quae</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #T1"/> </app> homo <app> <lem>concurrens</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">praecurrens</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1">recurrens</rdg> </app>, gratiam <locus target="#Pr1" from="131vb"/> <app> <lem>recuperaret</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">recuperavit</rdg> </app>; et ideo magnae misericordiae fuit <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">illa</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>instituere</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">institutio</rdg> </app>; <app> <lem>maxime</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>cum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">tamen</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>faciant</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">faciam</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">faciunt</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">sonum</witDetail> </app> solum ad remissionem culpae, sed <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #Pr1">etiam</rdg> </app> poenae. Decuit <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">enim</rdg> </app> etiam Dei iustitiam sacramenta instituere, <locus target="#K1" from="339a"/> quia cum sit iustus, exigebat aliqua <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">humilitatem</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">seu</rdg> </app> <locus target="#W5" from="92va"/> humiliationem per quam homo ad gratiam se disponeret, et sacramenta suscipiendo, quasi ex <app> <lem>quodam</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">quadam</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>pacto</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">pactu</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">facto</rdg> </app> gratiam <app> <lem>inveniret</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">crux</witDetail> </app>. <app> <lem>Decuit</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Confirmatio</witDetail> </app> etiam hoc <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">ad</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ipsum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">ipsam</rdg> </app> Dei sapientiam, <app> <lem>ut</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">quod</rdg> </app> sicut homo per <locus target="#Ox2" from="107rb"/> lignum <app> <lem>cecidit</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">cecudit</witDetail> </app>, ita per lignum salutis remedium inveniret. Expediens etiam fuit ex parte aegroti hominis <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">et</rdg> </app>, quia ex lapsu in peccatum erat homo caecus <app> <lem>quoad</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="ac">ad</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>rationalem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">rationalia</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">potentiam</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg"/> </app>; ideo, <locus target="#M9" from="98rb"/> data <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2 #T1">sint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ei</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sacramenta</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">visibilia</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>visibilia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sacramenta</rdg> </app> ad eruditionem. Erat <app> <lem>homo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">etiam</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>elatus</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">ilatus</rdg> </app> quoad <app> <lem>irascibilitatem</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">irascibilem</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">irascibilem potentiam</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">irascibilitatem</witDetail> </app>; ideo data <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Pr1 #T1">sint</rdg> </app> ei sacramenta corporalia ad sui humiliationem. <app> <lem>Erat</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">etiam</rdg> </app> <locus target="#U1" from="127rb"/> <app> <lem>etiam</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">erat</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>fastiditus</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">fastiticus</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">vastiditus</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">vasiditas</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>quoad</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">ad</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>concupiscibilitatem</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">concupiscibilem</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">id est concupiscibilem potentiam</witDetail> </app>, ut non <app> <lem>saperent</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">separent</rdg> </app> ei spiritualia; ideo instituta <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #Pr1 #T1 #W5">sint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">ei</rdg> </app> sacramenta ad exercitationem<note xml:id="snx003" type="source" source="#b-Bonav-Sent" n="3">lib. 4, dist. 1, p. 1, art. 1, q. 1, resp.</note>.” Patet <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ergo</rdg> </app> ex hac declaratione quod sacramenta <app> <lem>instituere</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">Deum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Deum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">instituere</rdg> </app> decuit et nobis expediens fuit. <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Confirmatur ratione</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Probatio conclusionis</witDetail> </app> probatur <app> <lem>ratione</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">conclusio</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>conclusio</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">ratione</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>: aliquo plus indiget aegrotus <app> <lem>quam</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="ac">vel</witDetail> </app> sanus, <app> <lem>ergo</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2">igitur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>aliquid</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ad</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>plus</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">oportuit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>oportuit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">plus</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>dari</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">dare</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>homini</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="del">ad</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>curando</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> ad salutem consequendam quam, si non caecidisset, <app> <lem>talia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">talis</rdg> </app> autem <app> <lem>non</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #Pr1 #T1">sint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>nisi</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="supl"/> </app> sacramenta, quia alias, homo si non caecidisset, habuisset gratiam, <app> <lem>virtutes</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">virtutis</rdg> </app> et dona, igitur <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9"/> </app>. Et confirmatur <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2"/> </app>: quia homo ignarus <app> <lem>fuit</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">quapropter</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app>, oportunum <locus target="#T1" from="126ra"/> et conveniens <app> <lem>erat</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sibi</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>dari</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">dare</rdg> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Wo1">erat</rdg> </app> praecepta legalia. Igitur, cum <app> <lem>etiam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2"/> </app> esset infirmus, pari ratione oportunum fuit <app> <lem>ipsa</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Pr1">ipsi</rdg> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">ipsa</witDetail> </app> provideri per sacramenta medicinalia <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">igitur</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">etc</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #W5" type="mg">Contra dictam conclusionem</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Contra</witDetail> </app> contra videtur quod <app> <lem>non</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="supl"/> </app> expediat aegroto quod sacramenta <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">sint</rdg> </app> instituta quia tanto melius est aegroto quanto <app> <lem>plures</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">primis</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>habet</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">vias</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>vias</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">habet</rdg> </app> veniendi ad salutem. Sed institutis sacramentis non est <app> <lem>alia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">aliqua</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>via</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="mg"/> </app> veniendi ad salutem quam per sacramenta. Prius vero erat omnis via qua se disponebat aegrotus ad gratiam. <app> <lem>Artata</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="subl"/> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">et</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ergo</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">autem</rdg> </app> via per sacramentorum <locus target="#K1" from="339b"/> <app> <lem>institutionem</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">non est expediens homini etc.</witDetail> </app>. <locus target="#Pr1" from="132ra"/> <app> <lem>Secundo</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Secundo ad idem</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="iter">Secundo</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app>: quamvis mandata servare non sit grave naturae sanae; est tamen grave naturae infirmae. <app> <lem>Ergo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">igitur</rdg> </app> multiplicare <app> <lem>mandata</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">non data</rdg> </app> non est nisi <app> <lem>gravare</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">generare</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc"/> </app> <locus target="#Ma1" from="152va"/> <app> <lem>sarcinam</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">si so.</witDetail> </app>. Igitur, si <app> <lem>sola</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">mandata essent</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>moralia</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">mortalia</rdg> </app> essent in <locus target="#Wo1" from="392rb"/> praecepto, <app> <lem>facilior</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">faciliter</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> esset <app> <lem>via</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> ad salutem <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">facilior</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>ergo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Ox2">igitur</rdg> </app> instituere ultra <app> <lem>hoc</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="del">mandata</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>sacramenta</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> est, ut videtur, <locus target="#Ox2" from="107va"/> viam salutis <app> <lem>aggravare</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">igitur videtur quod sacramenta non expediant</witDetail> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Solutio</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg"/> </app>: ad primum dico quod, si <app> <lem>plures</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">primis</rdg> </app> essent viae, nulla tamen <app> <lem>fuit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">esset</rdg> </app> ita <app> <lem>bona</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">utilis</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>nulla</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> ita <app> <lem>utilis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">bona</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>nulla</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>tam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1">ita</rdg> </app> efficax et <app> <lem>compendiosa</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">sicut via institutionis sacramentorum</witDetail> </app>. Et per hoc <app> <lem>responde</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">respondetur</rdg> </app> ad <app> <lem>formam</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">argumenti</witDetail> </app>. <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Ad secundum</witDetail> </app> secundum dico quod <app> <lem>aliquid</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">aliquod</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">quod</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>apparet</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">esse</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>onus</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">quod</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="ac">bonus</witDetail> </app> non tamen onerat, sed alleviat, <locus target="#W5" from="92vb"/> ut apparet in simili de <app> <lem>plumis</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">pluribus</rdg> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">pulmnis</witDetail> </app> et <app> <lem>pennis</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #T1">pellis</rdg> </app> in <app> <lem>avibus</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">navibus</witDetail> </app>. Non sequitur ergo, si sola moralia essent in praecepto, quod via <app> <lem>ad</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>salutem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">salutis</rdg> </app> esset facilior, immo <app> <lem>nunc</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">nec</rdg> </app> est facilior per sacramentorum adiutorium <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">etc</rdg> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Secunda</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">conclusio</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Secunda conclusio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="mg">Secunda</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>conclusio</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">secunda</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">est</rdg> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">scilicet</rdg> </app>: <locus target="#M9" from="98va"/> <label type="structure">Concl. 2</label> <app> <lem>quamvis</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Secunda conclusio</witDetail> </app> sacramenta ut sacramenta <app> <lem>semper</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>fuerunt</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #T1 #W5">fuerint</rdg> </app> remedia <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">semper</rdg> </app>; non tamen <app> <lem>quodlibet</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="del">tamen</witDetail> </app> sacramentum semper fuit remedium. <locus target="#U1" from="127va"/> Prima pars <app> <lem>huius</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2"/> </app> conclusionis patet <app> <lem>ex</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="ac">e</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>conclusione</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">praecedenti</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>praecedente</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">conclusione</rdg> <rdg wit="#Pr1">praecedenti</rdg> </app> et eius probatione. <app> <lem>Etiam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">et</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Pr1">ad</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">iuxta</rdg> </app> hanc intentionem loquuntur <app> <lem>doctores</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">doctoris</rdg> </app> qui dicunt quod sacramenta semper <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">sint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">et</rdg> </app> fuerunt <app> <lem>medicinae</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">medicina</rdg> </app>. <locus target="#T1" from="126rb"/> <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Secundus pars probatur</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">con.</witDetail> </app> secunda pars conclusionis probatur de matrimonio, <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">quia</rdg> </app> tempore innocentiae <app> <lem>primorum</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> parentum fuit institutum, ut patet <ref target="#snx004" type="source" n="4"/>Genesis, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">in</rdg> </app> secundo <app> <lem>capitulo</lem> <rdg wit="#T1"/> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="supl"/> </app><note xml:id="snx004" type="source" source="#b-B-Gen" subtype="cf" n="4">2, 22-24</note>. Sed <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">tunc</rdg> </app> non erat <app> <lem>tunc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> in remedium, <app> <lem>sicut</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">sed</witDetail> </app> nunc, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">sed</rdg> </app> quia tunc <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> <app> <lem>erat</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fuit</rdg> </app> opus <app> <lem>remedio</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">remedium</rdg> </app>, quia <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">tunc</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>tota</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">fuit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>fuit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">tota</rdg> </app> sanitas in <app> <lem>primis</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">puntis</witDetail> </app> parentibus, sed erat <app> <lem>solum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">solummodo</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> officium, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1 #Wo1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ex</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #Ox2" type="mg">Corrolarium</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">illa</rdg> </app> conclusione <app> <lem>sequitur</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">correlarie</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">correlarie</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> <label type="structure">Corr. 1</label> matrimonium aliquando fuit et non fuit sacramentum, prout sacramento attribuitur ratio medicinae aut remedii. Patet, quia in statu innocentiae fuit et tunc <locus target="#K1" from="340a"/> non fuit sacramentum, <app> <lem>saltim</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">saltem</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>illa</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">ista</rdg> </app> ratione, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app>. </p> <p rend="Title"> < <app> <lem>Articulus</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>II</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> > </p> <p> <app> <lem>Quantum</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #Ox2" type="mg">Secundus articulus</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="mg">Secundus</witDetail> </app> ad secundum articulum, <app> <lem>ponam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #T1">pono</rdg> </app> duas conclusiones <app> <lem>quarum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app> prima <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">est</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">illa</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app>, quod <label type="structure">Concl. 1</label> <app> <lem>significatio</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Prima conclusio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Conclusio prima</witDetail> </app> est de integritate sacramenti <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">fit</rdg> </app> quod omne sacramentum <locus target="#Pr1" from="132rb"/> significat et <app> <lem>est</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="del">sacramentum</witDetail> </app> signum. <app> <lem>Hanc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">hoc</rdg> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Probatio alia</witDetail> </app> conclusionem <app> <lem>declarat</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">probat</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Bonaventura</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">bona</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9"/> </app>: quia “<ref target="#snx005" type="source" n="5"/>sacramentalis <app> <lem>medicina</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">scilicet</witDetail> </app> est <app> <lem>sufficiens</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">efficiens</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>medicamen</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">medicinam</rdg> <rdg wit="#Pr1">medicina</rdg> </app>, quia ergo homo lapsus est non tantum in <app> <lem>pronitatem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">pronitate</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>contumeliae</lem> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="ac">conteumeliae</witDetail> </app>, <app> <lem>sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">etiam</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>caecitatem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">integritate</rdg> </app> ignorantiae; ideo <app> <lem>ut</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">quod</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>utroque</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">utrobique</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>curetur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">curaretur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sacramento</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">sacramentum</rdg> </app>, non tantum debet <app> <lem>habere</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">hoc</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Pr1">sacramentum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quid</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Pr1">quod</rdg> </app> gratuitum <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Pr1">est</rdg> </app>, sed etiam mysticum et <app> <lem>figuratum</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">vigoratum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>seu</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>significatum</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">significatibus</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app>”, per <app> <lem>quod</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">tunc excitetur opus iustitiae, sed illud timeri non uni.</witDetail> </app> <locus target="#Ox2" from="107vb"/> excitetur <app> <lem>motus</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">modus</rdg> </app> fidei, ratione cuius sacramenta <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #U1 #Wo1">sunt</rdg> </app> homini salutifera<note xml:id="snx005" type="source" source="#b-Bonav-Sent" n="5">lib. 4, dist. 1, p. 1, art. 1, q. 2, resp.</note>. Igitur conclusio <app> <lem>vera</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#U1">igitur etc</rdg> </app>. <app> <lem>Etiam</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Confirmatio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>haec</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>conclusio</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">patet</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>patet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">conclusio</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>per</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>diffinitiones</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">diffinitionem</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="in iter. 1">diffinitionem</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>sacramenti</lem> <rdg wit="#W5">sacramenta</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>quam</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>ponit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">Magister</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>Magister</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ponit</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">in distinctione</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>textu</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">scilicet</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">scilicet primam</witDetail> </app>: “<ref target="#snx006" type="source" n="6"/><app> <lem>sacramentum</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>sacrae</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>rei</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>signum</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app><note xml:id="snx006" type="source" source="#b-PLomb-Sent" n="6">lib. 4, dist. 1, cap. 2</note>”. <app> <lem>Et</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Confirmatur</witDetail> </app> confirmatur per illud quod dicit <app> <lem>venerabilis</lem> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="del">b.</witDetail> </app> Hugo quod “<ref target="#snx007" type="source" n="7"/>sacramentum est materiale elementum ex similitudine repraesentans, ex institutione significans<note xml:id="snx007" type="source" source="#b-HugoSV-DeSacram" subtype="cf" n="7">lib. 1, p. 9, cap. 2</note>”. <locus target="#Ma1" from="152vb"/> <app> <lem>Si</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>ergo</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">igitur</rdg> </app> sacramenta habent suum totum esse ex institutione et <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #Pr1 #T1">sint</rdg> </app> instituta ad significandum, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ideo</rdg> </app> significare est <app> <lem>eis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">eius</rdg> </app> essentiale, quod <app> <lem>fuit</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">sint</rdg> </app> probandum. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Secunda</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">conclusio</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2 #T1" type="mg">Secunda conclusio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Conclusio secunda</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="mg">Secunda</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>conclusio</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">secunda</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">illa</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1 #Wo1"/> </app>: <label type="structure">Concl. 2</label> quamvis commune sit omnibus sacramentis <locus target="#U1" from="127vb"/> consistere in aliquibus rebus gratiam Dei significantibus; tamen speciale est <app> <lem>sacramentis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sacramentum</rdg> </app> novae Legis, <locus target="#T1" from="126va"/> <app> <lem>ut</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>consistant</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">consistat</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">consistere</rdg> <rdg wit="#T1">consistent</rdg> </app> in <app> <lem>verbis</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">verbus</rdg> </app> et <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">in</rdg> </app> rebus. Prima pars <app> <lem>huius</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">conclusionis</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>conclusionis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">huius</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">probatur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">et</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>patet</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="ac">partet</witDetail> </app> per praecedentem <app> <lem>conclusionem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>. <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> secunda <app> <lem>pars</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> probatur <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app>: quia <locus target="#W5" from="93ra"/> <app> <lem>taliter</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">debebant</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>debebant</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">taliter</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">debent</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5"/> </app> <app> <lem>institui</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="ac">instituti</witDetail> </app> sacramenta novae Legis, <app> <lem>ut</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="supl"/> </app> non solum <app> <lem>gratiam</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> significarent, verum <app> <lem>etiam</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">ut</witDetail> </app> personam Salvatoris <app> <lem>repraesentarent</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">repraesentant</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">repraesentare</rdg> </app> ex cuius passione habent <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">etiam</rdg> </app> efficaciam respectu gratiae <app> <lem>quam</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">omnes igitur homo</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>omnes</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">homines</rdg> </app> recipiunt, <app> <lem>qui</lem> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="del">rei</witDetail> </app> rite percipiunt <app> <lem>huiusmodi</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">huius</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">huiusmodi</witDetail> </app> sacramenta. <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="supl"/> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Notabile</witDetail> </app> in persona Salvatoris est verbum aeternum unitum <locus target="#M9" from="98vb"/> sensibili <app> <lem>corpori</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">corporali</rdg> </app>, igitur sacramenta novae Legis debent consistere in verbis et <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">in</rdg> </app> rebus sensibilibus, <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #Pr1 #Wo1"/> </app> igitur conclusio vera <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">etc</rdg> </app>. </p> <p rend="Title"> < Articulus III > </p> <p> <app> <lem>Quantum</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #Ox2 #W5" type="mg">Tertius articulus</witDetail> </app> ad tertium articulum, <app> <lem>ponam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #T1 #Wo1">pono</rdg> </app> tres conclusiones <app> <lem>quarum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>prima</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">primam</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">est</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Pr1">illa</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <label type="structure">Concl. 1</label> in statu <locus target="#K1" from="340b"/> innocentiae nec fuit necessarium nec oportunum <app> <lem>aliquod</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">esse</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>esse</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">aliquod</rdg> </app> sacramentum. Probatur <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app>: <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> ubi nulla fuit infirmitas, ibi non fuit <app> <lem>medicinae</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">necessitas</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>necessitas</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">medicinae</rdg> </app>. Sed in statu innocentiae <app> <lem>nulla</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">non</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="del">ullo</witDetail> </app> fuit infirmitas. <locus target="#Pr1" from="132va"/> Et quia gratia sacramentalis <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">animae</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>animae</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">est</rdg> </app> medicina, igitur conclusio vera. Maior patet <locus target="#Wo1" from="392va"/> ex <app> <lem>illo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">illa</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">isto</rdg> <rdg wit="#Pr1">ista</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#T1 #U1 #W5">quia</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>habetur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1">habentur</rdg> </app> Matthaei <app> <lem>nono</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app>: “<ref target="#snx008" type="source" n="8"/>non est opus <app> <lem>valentibus</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">id est sanis</witDetail> </app> medicus, sed male habentibus<note xml:id="snx008" type="source" source="#b-B-Matth" n="8">9, 12</note>”. <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Prima pars</witDetail> </app> minor <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">autem</rdg> </app> pro prima parte <app> <lem>patet</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> quia infirmitas animae est <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> peccato sed in statu innocentiae <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">tunc</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>nullum</lem> <rdg wit="#W5"/> </app> <app> <lem>erat</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fuit</rdg> </app> peccatum <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">sequitur quod ista conclusio pro prima parte sit vera</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">Sed in statu innocentiae nullum fuit peccatum, igitur etc.</witDetail> </app>. <locus target="#Ox2" from="108ra"/> <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Secunda pars</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">propter</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>pro</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">per</rdg> </app> secunda parte <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2">patet</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1">patet per</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>minor</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">minorum</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>patet</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">probatur</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Ox2"/> </app> per <app> <lem>venerabilem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>Hugonem</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">Hugo</rdg> <rdg wit="#Wo1">Hugonis</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">de Sancto Victore</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc"/> </app> <app> <lem>qui</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>dicit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">dicentem</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc"/> </app> quod “<ref target="#snx009" type="source" n="9"/>sacramenta <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sunt</rdg> </app> vasa medicinalia<note xml:id="snx009" type="source" source="#b-HugoSV-DeSacram" subtype="cf" n="9">lib. 1, p. 9, cap. 4</note>”, quod dicit propter gratiam quae cum sacramentis confertur per modum medicinae. <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Contra dicta</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Contra</witDetail> </app> forte <app> <lem>diceret</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">dicit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quis</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">contra</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>contra</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">quis</rdg> </app> per argumentum ante oppositum. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Solutio</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Solutio argumenti primi secundum oppositum</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="mg">Responsium</witDetail> </app>: quamvis <app> <lem>homo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> indiguisset <app> <lem>gratia</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">gratiam</rdg> </app>, non tamen indiguisset <app> <lem>ea</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">eam</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>contra</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">propter</witDetail> </app> peccatorum vulnera, et ideo non indiguisset ea ut <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> sacramentalis <app> <lem>vel</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">et</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">et</witDetail> </app> medicinalis. Et per hoc patet ad formam. <app> <lem>Etiam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">et</rdg> </app>, si opponitur <app> <lem>de</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="ac">dema.</witDetail> </app> matrimonio, responsum <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> supra: quia in statu innocentiae fuit institutum in officium, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">nunc</rdg> <rdg wit="#Wo1">modo</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Wo1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">autem</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>simul</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>officium</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> et <locus target="#T1" from="126vb"/> remedium, <app> <lem>sed</lem><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Ox2 #Pr1 #T1 #U1 #Wo1">sicut</rdg> </app> nunc <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">simul</rdg> </app> in statu post lapsum <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">etc</rdg> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Secunda</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #Ox2" type="mg">Secunda conclusio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="mg">Propositio</witDetail> </app> conclusio <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">illa</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app>: <label type="structure">Concl. 2</label> post lapsum hominis in peccatum pro quocumque statu viae, <app> <lem>puta</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">scilicet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>pro</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> statu legis naturae, mosaicae et evangelicae semper utilia et congrua, et quodammodo necessaria <app> <lem>fuerunt</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">fuerint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>homini</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">hominum</rdg> </app> divina sacramenta. <app> <lem>Alia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">aliter</rdg> </app> tamen et <app> <lem>alia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">aliter</rdg> </app> puta magis perfecta <locus target="#Ma1" from="153ra"/> et minus perfecta secundum exigentiam <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">scilicet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>statuum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">diversorum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>diversorum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">statuum</rdg> </app>. Probatur <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #Wo1"/> </app>: quia in quocumque <locus target="#U1" from="128ra"/> statu durat infirmitas, pro <app> <lem>illo</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">isto</rdg> </app> statu est utilis et necessaria medicina; <app> <lem>sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Nota</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>post</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">plus</rdg> </app> lapsum hominis <app> <lem>a</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">in</rdg> </app> statu innocentiae <locus target="#K1" from="341a"/> pro quocumque statu viae <app> <lem>duravit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #U1">durabit</rdg> </app> infirmitas, igitur <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>. Et dico quodammodo <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">est</rdg> </app> necessaria, quia Deus <app> <lem>alia</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">alio</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>via</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">modo</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>potuisset</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">bene</witDetail> </app> salutem dedisse <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">etc</rdg> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Tertia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #M9">conclusio</rdg> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Conclusio tertia</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Conclusio tertia</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="mg">Propositio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>conclusio</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #M9">tertia</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Ox2 #Wo1"/> </app> <locus target="#W5" from="93rb"/> <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Ox2 #Wo1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <label type="structure">Concl. 3</label> in <app> <lem>statu</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="ac">stitu</witDetail> </app> patriae <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">nec</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fuit nec est</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>necessarium</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">congruum</rdg> </app>, nec <app> <lem>congruum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">necessarium</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="del">nec</witDetail> </app> esse aliquod sacramentum. Probatur <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app>: <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ubi</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ibi</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Wo1" type="ac">ubicumque</witDetail> </app> <locus target="#Pr1" from="132vb"/> est perfecta sanitas cum <app> <lem>impossibilitate</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">impassibilitate</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc"/> </app> infirmitatis, <app> <lem>ibi</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">igitur</rdg> </app> nulla est <app> <lem>opportunitas</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">medicinae</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>medicinae</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">opportunitas</rdg> </app>. Sed <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #U1 #W5"/> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="supl"/> </app> patria est tanta et <app> <lem>tam</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">tamen</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> perfecta sanitas spiritualis quod <app> <lem>impossibilis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">impossibile</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1"/> </app> ibi <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">esse</rdg> </app> aliqua <app> <lem>infirmitas</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">infirmitatem</rdg> </app>, igitur non <locus target="#M9" from="99ra"/> est opportunum, nec <app> <lem>congruum</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="pc"/> </app> ibi esse aliquod sacramentum, cum sacramenta <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sunt</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> medicinae <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">est</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>remedia</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">remedium</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Wo1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Wo1">Et sic est finis conclusionis</rdg> </app>. </p> <p rend="TitleCaps"> < Replicationes > </p> <p> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#W5 #Wo1">sequitur</rdg> <witDetail wit="#M9 #T1 #U1" type="mg">Collatio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="rubr.">Collatio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="mg">Sequitur replicatio et collatio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#W5">nota</rdg> <rdg wit="#Wo1">collatio</rdg> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="rubr."/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Wo1">etc</rdg> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="rubr."/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">nunc expeditus etc.</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5">replicationem</rdg> </app> Nunc <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">igitur</rdg> </app> expeditus de positione <app> <lem>praesentis</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">conclusio</witDetail> </app> quaestionis, <app> <lem>descendo</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">descendam</rdg> </app> ad aliquas <app> <lem>materias</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> tractatas in <ref target="#snx010" type="source" n="10"/>prioribus meis principiis<note xml:id="snx010" type="source" source="#b-ConrSoltau-Sent" subtype="cf" n="10">lib. 1, pr.; lib. 2, pr.; lib. 3, pr.</note> in quibus confero cum dominis et magistris meis. </p> <p rend="Title"> < Replicatio I > </p> <p> Et <app> <lem>primo</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">quod</witDetail> </app> ad materiam in qua confero cum magistro <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">meo</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Mensone</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">Mansone</rdg> </app>, qui <label type="structure">Obiectio 1</label> <app> <lem>impugnat</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">impugnavit</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Ox2" from="108rb"/> <app> <lem>istam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Pr1">illam</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">primam</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>conclusionem</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">istam conclusionem in primo</witDetail> </app> in <app> <lem>primo</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> principio <app> <lem>positam</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">prius scilicet primam</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">quod</rdg> </app>: <ref target="#snx011" type="source" n="11"/><app> <lem>Ex</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Conclusio prima</witDetail> </app> studio sacrae Scripturae <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #T1">nec</rdg> </app> acquiritur, <app> <lem>nec</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc"/> </app> acquiri potest habitus theologicus sine fide<note xml:id="snx011" type="source" source="#b-ConrSoltau-Sent" subtype="cf" n="11">lib. 1, pr., q. 1, art. 1, co. 4</note>. Quam probavi sic: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1</label> quia principia ad <app> <lem>talem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">talis</rdg> </app> habitum <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2 #Pr1">sint</rdg> </app> articuli fidei, ex quibus procedi non potest nisi sint crediti. Et <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="supl"/> </app> non <app> <lem>possunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">potest</rdg> </app> <locus target="#T1" from="127ra"/> credi in lumine <app> <lem>naturalis</lem> <witDetail wit="#Wo1" type="del">visionis igitur</witDetail> </app> cognitionis, igitur <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Responsio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>istud</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Ox2 #Pr1">illud</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="ac">istam</witDetail> </app> argumentum <app> <lem>respondet</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ipse</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1">sic</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">respondet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ipse</rdg> </app>: <label type="structure">Ob. 1.2</label> quod minor habet duas partes. <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.2</label> Ad primam dicit <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">sic</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">loq.</witDetail> </app> vel loquitur illa <app> <lem>prima</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> pars <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">primi</rdg> </app> minoris de principiis effectivis, et hoc non, quia tunc articuli fidei habitu theologico non <app> <lem>cognoscerentur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">cognoscuntur</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">cognoscantur</rdg> </app> altiori lumine quam lumine fidei, cuius oppositum dicit <app> <lem>positio</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">mea</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>mea</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">positio</rdg> </app>. Et allegavi ad hoc <ref target="#snx012" type="source" n="12"/><app> <lem>Doctorem</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #W5" type="mg">Heinricus de Gandavo</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="mg">Henricum de Gandawo</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="mg">Hinricus de Gandavo</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">Henricus de Gandavo</rdg> </app> Sollemnem <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">scilicet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2 #U1">Heinricus de Gandavo</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">et</witDetail> </app>, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">tertio</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Quolibet</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">to</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>quintodecimo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">tertio</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app>, quaestione secunda<note xml:id="snx012" type="source" source="#b-HenrGand-Quodl15" subtype="cf" n="12">q. 2,?????????</note>; vel loquitur <app> <lem>illa</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ista</rdg> </app> minor de principio <app> <lem>formali</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">materiali</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">vel</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>materiali</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">formali</rdg> </app> vel finali et super hoc <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> deductionem <app> <lem>suam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>facit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fecit</rdg> <rdg wit="#Pr1">faciat</rdg> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Videtur</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">N.</witDetail> </app> mihi quod <label type="structure">Ob. 1.3</label> magister meus <app> <lem>vult</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">velit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>me</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> per <app> <lem>illud</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">hoc</rdg> </app> argumentum <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Wo1">me</rdg> </app> compellere ad legendum <ref target="#snx013" type="source" n="13"/>primum Posteriorum<note xml:id="snx013" type="source" source="#b-Arist-AnalPoster" subtype="cf" n="13">?????????</note>, quod non <app> <lem>facio</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">libenter</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>libenter</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">facio</rdg> </app> coram <app> <lem>tot</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> occulatis viris. Dico tamen quod <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.3</label> <app> <lem>principia</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">principaliter</rdg> </app> scientiarum <app> <lem>ex</lem> <witDetail wit="#Wo1" type="ac">de</witDetail> </app> quibus devenimus in <app> <lem>conclusiones</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">conclusionem</rdg> </app> non <locus target="#K1" from="341b"/> <app> <lem>concurrunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">currunt</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Pr1" from="133ra"/> ad notitiam conclusionum <app> <lem>acquirendam</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">ad quaerendam</rdg> </app> in genere causae materialis, nec <app> <lem>finalis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">formalis</rdg> </app>, nec <app> <lem>formalis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">finalis</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">tantum</witDetail> </app> in genere <locus target="#U1" from="128rb"/> causae efficientis, quia <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #U1 #W5 #Wo1">sunt</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Wo1" from="392vb"/> causae <app> <lem>efficientes</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">efficientis</rdg> </app> instrumentales nostrum intellectum disponentes et <app> <lem>elevantes</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">lenevantes</rdg> </app> ad notitiam conclusionum quarum <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #Pr1">sint</rdg> </app> principia. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Solutio</witDetail> </app> ad argumentum suum <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">quo arguit</rdg> </app> in contrarium <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">conclusioni</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>arguit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9"/> </app>: <label type="structure">Ob. 1.4</label> quia <app> <lem>tunc</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> per habitum <app> <lem>theologicum</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">ef.</witDetail> </app> ex studio <app> <lem>Scripturae</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sacrae</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sacrae</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">Scripturae</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">sacro</rdg> </app> acquisitum non <app> <lem>cognoscerentur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">cognoscuntur</rdg> </app> articuli fidei <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">in</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Ma1" from="153rb"/> <app> <lem>lumine</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">ar.</witDetail> </app> altiori quam lumine <app> <lem>fidei</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">igitur</witDetail> </app>, <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.4</label> nego <app> <lem>illam</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #U1">istam</rdg> </app> consequentiam et dico quod per nullum studium potest <app> <lem>haberi</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">acquiri</rdg> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="mg">haberi</witDetail> </app> notitia de articulis fidei nisi cum adiutorio <locus target="#W5" from="93va"/> habitus <app> <lem>infusi</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="ac">infuse</witDetail> </app>. Sed <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">ex</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>illo</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">isto</rdg> </app> habitu infuso una cum studio <app> <lem>sacrae</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">Scripturae</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Scripturae</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">sacrae</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Ox2" from="108va"/> articuli fidei <app> <lem>cognoscuntur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">cognoscantur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>altiori</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">clariori</rdg> </app> lumine et <app> <lem>clariori</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">altiori</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">lumine</rdg> </app> quam lumine <app> <lem>solius</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> habitus infusi, et <app> <lem>haec</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">hoc</rdg> </app> fuit intentio beati <app> <lem>Augustini</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">libro</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>quartodecimo</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">quintodecimo</rdg> </app> De Trinitate, capitulo primo, ubi loquens de sacra <app> <lem>Scriptura</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">theologia</rdg> </app> sic dicit: “<ref target="#snx014" type="source" n="14"/>huic scientiae <app> <lem>tribuendum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">adtribuendum</rdg> </app> est [...] quo fides <app> <lem>saluberrima</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">salubriam</rdg> </app> gignitur”, <app> <lem>scilicet</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> in aliis “defenditur, nutritur et roboratur<note xml:id="snx014" type="source" source="#b-Aug-DeTrin" n="14">lib. 14, c. 1, n. 3</note>”. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Et</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Confirmatur</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Contra</witDetail> </app> forte <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5"/> </app> ex <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Ox2">illa</rdg> </app> auctoritate <app> <lem>argueret</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">arguet</rdg> </app> sic: <label type="structure">Ob. 1.5</label> si fides <app> <lem>per</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">habet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>theologicum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">habitum</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="del">g.</witDetail> </app> <locus target="#M9" from="99rb"/> <app> <lem>habitum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">theologicum</rdg> </app> gignitur in <locus target="#T1" from="127rb"/> <app> <lem>aliis</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">eis</rdg> </app>, scilicet <app> <lem>per</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">prae</rdg> </app> praedicationem Evangelii, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="ac">et</witDetail> </app> sine habitu <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">etiam</rdg> </app> infuso <app> <lem>posset</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">potest</rdg> </app> quis habere scientiam de pure credibilibus, quia per habitum sic genitum. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Solutio</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Solutio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Responsio</witDetail> </app>. <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.5</label> Nego consequentiam: <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">et</rdg> </app> dico quod praedicatio Evangelii <app> <lem>sicut</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">sic</rdg> </app> disponit audientes et fidem <app> <lem>habentes</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">et</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>ad</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg"/> </app> caritatem et <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #M9">ad</rdg> </app> alia dona, sic potest disponere ad fidem quam tamen Deus infundit. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Et</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Contra</witDetail> </app> ex istis ego respondeo ad <app> <lem>unum</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">quam</witDetail> </app> quod <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> <locus target="#K1" from="342a"/> quaerit a me <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">scilicet</rdg> </app>: <label type="structure">Ob. 1.6</label> si articuli fidei cognoscuntur altiori lumine quam lumine fidei, unde nascitur illud lumen <app> <lem>altius</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">alterius</rdg> </app>? <app> <lem>Dico</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">quod</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Responsio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">quot</rdg> </app> <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.6</label> ex fide et <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">ex</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Pr1" from="133rb"/> studio <app> <lem>Scripturae</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sacrae</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sacrae</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">Scripturae</rdg> </app>, quia habita <app> <lem>fide</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">ex stud.</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">et</rdg> </app> studio <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sacrae</rdg> </app> Scripturae <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">sacrae</rdg> </app> homo incipit <app> <lem>clarius</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> cognoscere credibilia fidei quam sola <app> <lem>fide</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="ac">fidei</witDetail> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item responsio</witDetail> </app> unum <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">argumentum</rdg> </app> de argumentis meis <app> <lem>respondet</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">praedictus</witDetail> </app> magister meus <app> <lem>reverendus</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">cum</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#U1">sic</rdg> </app> cum <app> <lem>arguebam</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">arguebatur</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">arguebat</witDetail> </app> sic: <label type="structure">Ob. 1.7</label> si <app> <lem>posset</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">possit</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">potest</rdg> </app> acquiri habitus <app> <lem>cognitivus</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">congruentivus</rdg> </app> sine fide de <app> <lem>pure</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">puris</rdg> </app> credibilibus, <app> <lem>sequitur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">sequeretur</rdg> </app> quod non essent <app> <lem>pure</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #Wo1">pura</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">seu pure</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">ce.</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>credibilia</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">dico negando</witDetail> </app>, <app> <lem>negando</lem><rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Ox2 #W5 #Wo1">nego</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc">negat</witDetail> </app> consequentiam. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1"/> </app> ad probationem cum dico <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">quasi</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>praedicantur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">principia</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1">dicantur</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">ad probationem cum dico praedicantur pure credibilia ipse respondet sic quod</witDetail> </app> <locus target="#Ox2" from="108vb"/> pure credibilia <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Pr1">etc</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> respondet <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>: <label type="structure">Ob. 1.8</label> <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">quod</rdg> </app> sine <app> <lem>fide</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fidei</rdg> </app> cognosci <app> <lem>non</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="del">habent</witDetail> </app> valent absolute loquendo <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">sed</rdg> </app> de fide. <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.8</label> Sed ego <app> <lem>locutus</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">sum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">locutus</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> sine fide <locus target="#U1" from="128va"/> Ecclesiae. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Contra</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Contra dicta</witDetail> </app>: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.7-1.8</label> tunc ex <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">illa</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>solutione</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">sua</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sua</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">solutione</rdg> </app> sequitur quod non <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sunt</rdg> </app> aliter <app> <lem>pure</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> credibilia quam <app> <lem>quaecumque</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">quacumque</rdg> </app> alia vera <app> <lem>vel</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">et</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>etiam</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="supl"/> </app> falsa, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Pr1">antecedens</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1 #Pr1">patet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>quaecumque</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>alia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>vera</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>vel</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>etiam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>falsa</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, aliqua <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Ox2 #Pr1">sint</rdg> </app> sic bene <app> <lem>pure</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="mg"/> </app> credibilia, quia non <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2 #Pr1">sint</rdg> </app> inquisitive credibilia, sed falsitas. Patet quia doctores vocant articulos de Trinitate <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">scilicet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>incarnatione</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">incarnationem</rdg> </app> pure <app> <lem>credibiles</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">credibilia</rdg> </app>, quia sine lumine <app> <lem>supernaturali</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">naturali</rdg> </app>, scilicet <app> <lem>fidei</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">fide</rdg> </app> infusae, quod patet per beatum Augustinum qui dicit <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">quod</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>de</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>talibus</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>: “<ref target="#snx015" type="source" n="15"/>ex fide credidisti, fides <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>te</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> donum <app> <lem>Dei</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">est</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">Dei</rdg> </app><note xml:id="snx015" type="source" source="#b-Aug-Serm168" n="15">n. 1/1</note>”. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Solutio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>dicta</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sancta</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>multa</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">multorum</rdg> <rdg wit="#Pr1">in littera</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> sanctorum quae allegavi pro mea <locus target="#T1" from="127va"/> <app> <lem>positione</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">praedictas</witDetail> </app> respondet <app> <lem>magister</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> meus <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">reverendus</rdg> </app> ad omnia <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">in</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>isto</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">illo</rdg> </app> fundamento: <label type="structure">Ob. 1.9</label> <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">quod</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>loquatur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">loquitur</rdg> <rdg wit="#Wo1">loquantur</rdg> </app> de fide formata. </p> <p> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">sed</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Contra</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Contra dicta</witDetail> </app>: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.9</label> fides quantum ad formam suam <app> <lem>quae</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>caritas</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> facit credere ex dilectione <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">quae est caritas</rdg> </app>. Sed <app> <lem>ille</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">auctoritates</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">iste</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Ma1" from="153va"/> <app> <lem>auctoritates</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ille</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>loquuntur</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">dicuntur</rdg> </app> de credere simpliciter. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Etiam</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">et</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> respondendo ad <app> <lem>illas</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #U1">istas</rdg> </app> auctoritates dicit quod intelliguntur <locus target="#W5" from="93vb"/> sic: <label type="structure">Ob. 1.10</label> quia <app> <lem>articulos</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">articulis</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Wo1" from="393ra"/> fidei non <app> <lem>potest</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">possunt</rdg> </app> quis <app> <lem>inquisitive</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">attingere</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>attingere</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">inquisitive</rdg> </app>; stat <app> <lem>tamen</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">autem</rdg> </app> quod <app> <lem>aliquis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">alias</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>fit</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2 #Pr1">sit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>fidelis</lem> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="ac">fideles</witDetail> </app> ex fide probi <app> <lem>viri</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">viti</witDetail> </app> ipsum informantis. </p> <p> <locus target="#K1" from="342b"/> <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Contra dicta</witDetail> </app> contra: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.10</label> <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>dictis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>suis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> haeretici possunt informare <app> <lem>aliquod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #U1">aliquem</rdg> </app> quod credat multa <locus target="#Pr1" from="133va"/> falsa. <app> <lem>Etiam</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ecce</rdg> </app> qui credit falsa habet <app> <lem>quidem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">quaedam</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #Pr1">quandam</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">fidem</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">ad</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>adhaesionem</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">quod</witDetail> </app>, sed <app> <lem>nullam</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> <app> <lem>cognitionem</lem> <rdg wit="#W5">convinctionem</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>falsa</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sciuntur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>nec</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>cognoscuntur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app>, igitur <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Post</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Dicitur</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>praemissa</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">praedicta</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>magister</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">quaerit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quaerit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">magister</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">meus</rdg> </app> <label type="structure">Ob. 1.11</label> <app> <lem>quid</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">quod</rdg> </app> ego <app> <lem>sentiam</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">de arria.</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>de</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">ad</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Arrianis</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">arrigionis</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">de</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Pelagianis</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">pelagionis</rdg> </app> et <locus target="#M9" from="99va"/> <app> <lem>aliis</lem> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="del">e</witDetail> </app> haereticis, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">quando</rdg> </app> dixi sibi respondendo ad unum <app> <lem>de</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> <app> <lem>suis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">argumentis</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>argumentis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">suis</rdg> </app> quod magister in theologia factus haereticus non <app> <lem>posset</lem> <rdg wit="#T1 #U1">potest</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">possum</rdg> </app> informare Iudaeum vel paganum de habitu theologico sine fide, quia nec <app> <lem>hoc</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">haec</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>posset</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #U1">potest</rdg> </app> magister fidelis et devotus. <app> <lem>Dico</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Solutio</witDetail> </app> quod <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.11</label> fides requiritur non solum <app> <lem>propter</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">super</rdg> </app> adhaesionem, ut magister meus <app> <lem>communiter</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">convenit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>assumere</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">assentire</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">assentiare</witDetail> </app> videtur, sed etiam <locus target="#Ox2" from="109ra"/> propter sequentem cognitionem, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ut</rdg> </app> dicit Isaias: “<ref target="#snx016" type="source" n="16"/>nisi credideritis non intelligetis<note xml:id="snx016" type="source" source="#b-B-Is" n="16">7, 9</note>”. Et ita loquitur beatus <ref target="#snx017" type="source" n="17"/>Augustinus in libro <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Pr1">secundo</rdg> </app> De libero arbitrio<note xml:id="snx017" type="source" source="#b-Aug-DeLibArb" n="17">lib. 2, n. 2/5</note>. Sed dico quod in <app> <lem>illis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">istis</rdg> </app> haereticis <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">non</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>fuit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">sint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>adhaesio</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">adhaesiones</rdg> </app> sine fide et ideo <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">ibi</rdg> </app> non fuit <app> <lem>ibi</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">sibi</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>habitus</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="exp">theologico</witDetail> </app> theologicus, quia non fuit cognitivus. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Deinde</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Conclusio alia</witDetail> </app> magister meus <label type="structure">Obiectio 2</label> inpugnat <app> <lem>illam</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #U1">istam</rdg> </app> <ref target="#snx018" type="source" n="18"/>conclusionem <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">meam</rdg> </app> quod <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">etiam</rdg> </app> <locus target="#U1" from="128vb"/> aliquibus <app> <lem>traditis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">credetis</rdg> </app> in sacra Scriptura potest acquiri habitus <locus target="#T1" from="127vb"/> <app> <lem>sine</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="exp">theologia</witDetail> </app> fide<note xml:id="snx018" type="source" source="#b-ConrSoltau-Sent" subtype="cf" n="18">lib. 1, pr., q. 1, art. 1, co. 2</note>, quam probavi sic: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2</label> <app> <lem>quia</lem> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="ac">qua</witDetail> </app> aliqua <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #U1">sunt</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ibi</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">tradita</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>tradita</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ibi</rdg> </app> quae <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #T1 #U1 #Wo1">sunt</rdg> </app> pure <app> <lem>moralia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">naturalia</rdg> </app> et <app> <lem>naturalia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">moralia</rdg> </app>. </p> <p> Circa hoc impugnando <app> <lem>quaerit</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">ad</witDetail> </app>: <label type="structure">Ob. 2.2</label> an <app> <lem>iste</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9">ille</rdg> </app> habitus sit de integritate Scripturae, <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ut</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>habeant</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">habeatur</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">habeat</rdg> </app> respectum ad subiectum. </p> <p> Dico quod, <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.2</label> sicut <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> scientia morali assumitur aliquid de scientia naturali, quod ut <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">sit</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">nec</witDetail> </app> assumptum <app> <lem>habet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">habent</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>respectum</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="del">si</witDetail> </app> ad subiectum <app> <lem>seorsum</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="ac">deorsum</witDetail> </app>, <app> <lem>tamen</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">potest</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>potest</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">tamen</rdg> </app> haberi sine scientia <app> <lem>morali</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">sicut illud quod ph. Philosophus in fine Ethicorum, ut sequitur in alia latere, non est defectus in iste spatio</witDetail> </app>, <locus target="#Ox2" from="109rb"/> sicut illud quod <ref target="#snx019" type="source" n="19"/><app> <lem>Philosophus</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">habet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">infirme</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>fine</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>primi</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #W5"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">libro</rdg> </app> Ethicorum<note xml:id="snx019" type="source" source="#b-Arist-EthNic" subtype="cf" n="19">lib. 1, cap. 13, 1102a14-1103a11</note> tractat de potentiis animae, <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">sicut</rdg> </app> in proposito <locus target="#K1" from="343a"/> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">igitur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Pr1">etc</rdg> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ultimo</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">ulterius</rdg> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Solutio alia</witDetail> </app> dico quod conclusio <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">illa</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> magistri mei <app> <lem>reverendi</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #T1"/> </app> non est sustinenda <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> qua <app> <lem>dicere</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">videtur</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9">dicetur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">et</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>videtur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">dicere</rdg> </app> contra me quod <label type="structure">Ob. 2.3</label> ex studio <app> <lem>sacrae</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">Scripturae</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Scripturae</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">sacrae</rdg> </app> possit acquiri habitus ultra fidem cognitivus sine fide, quia si credibile potest credi et per intellectum cognosci sine fide, <app> <lem>sequitur</lem> <rdg wit="#W5">se</rdg> </app> quod amabile <app> <lem>possit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #T1 #U1">posset</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>amari</lem> <rdg wit="#W5">amare</rdg> </app> sine caritate. <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.3</label> Consequens <locus target="#Pr1" from="133vb"/> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>erroneum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">falsum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>consequentia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">patet</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>patet</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">consequentia</rdg> </app>: <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">quod</rdg> </app> voluntas <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ex</rdg> </app> sua natura non est minoris facultatis <app> <lem>respectu</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">respectui</witDetail> </app> sui obiecti proprii quam intellectus respectu sui. <app> <lem>Et</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Responsio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>si</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> forte vellet dicere quod voluntas sine caritate <app> <lem>posset</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">potest</rdg> </app> diligere naturali dilectione, sed non meritoria. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Contra</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Contra</witDetail> </app>: <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">quia</rdg> </app> <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.3.1</label> recte, sicut <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> arguit, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">quod</rdg> </app> quis potest <app> <lem>moveri</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">movi</rdg> </app> ad credendum non <locus target="#W5" from="94ra"/> accedente <locus target="#Ma1" from="153vb"/> fide infusa, sic potest quis <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> fortius, <app> <lem>scilicet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">circa</rdg> </app> per rationes <app> <lem>metaphysicales</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">mathematicales</rdg> </app> et morales moveri ad amandum igitur amatio sine caritate infusa <app> <lem>posset</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">potest</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>esse</lem> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="ac">esset</witDetail> </app> tam intensa sicut ex caritate, <app> <lem>quare</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">qua</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">gratia</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ergo</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> non esset meritoria. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Item</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Contra dicta</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item</witDetail> </app>, <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.3.2</label> <app> <lem>si</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> fundamentum magistri <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">mei</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>esset</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">est</rdg> </app> sustinendum, tunc fides ut habitus infusus et ut virtus theologica esset omnino frustra. <app> <lem>Et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">vel</rdg> </app> dicat <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> pro informatione scholae ad <locus target="#M9" from="99vb"/> quid <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #T1">sic</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ponenda</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sustinenda</rdg> </app> fides infusa <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">et ponenda</rdg> </app>, si sine ea <app> <lem>possunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">possint</rdg> </app> credi omnia. </p> <p> <locus target="#T1" from="128ra"/> <app> <lem>Item</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Solutio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item</witDetail> </app>, <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.3.3</label> ex fundamento rationis <app> <lem>praemisse</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">praedictae</rdg> </app> capiatur <app> <lem>unus</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="ac">una</witDetail> </app> secundum <app> <lem>intentionem</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="iter"/> </app> <locus target="#Ox2" from="109va"/> magistri <app> <lem>mei</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">magistri</rdg> </app> sic: de credibilibus <app> <lem>informatus</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">formatus</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">quod</witDetail> </app> quod credat et informetur <locus target="#U1" from="129ra"/> <app> <lem>ille</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">iste</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="iter"/> </app> fieri <app> <lem>potest</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">posset</rdg> </app>, pari ratione <app> <lem>quod</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>diligat</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="supl"/> </app> diligenda et <app> <lem>speret</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sperat</rdg> </app> speranda. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Item</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">iste</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item</witDetail> </app>, <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.3.4</label> ex puris naturalibus <locus target="#Wo1" from="393rb"/> <app> <lem>merebitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">mereretur</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">merebintur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>vitam</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">vita</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>aeternam</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">aeterna</rdg> </app>, quod est haeresis Pelagii, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">igitur</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1 #Wo1"/> </app>. </p> <p rend="Title"> < Replicatio II > </p> <p> <app> <lem>Nunc</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Sequitur alia</witDetail> </app> consequenter venio <locus target="#K1" from="343b"/> ad <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">unam</rdg> </app> materiam <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">cum</rdg> </app> qua <app> <lem>confero</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> cum magistro meo <app> <lem>reverendo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #T1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">magistro</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>Nicolao</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #T1">Nycolao</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc">Nycolao</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>de</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Ox2 #Pr1 #T1 #U1 #W5 #Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem>Gubin</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Pr1">Gubyn</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">Cobyn</rdg> <rdg wit="#T1">Gobyn</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5">Guwin</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">Cobbyn</witDetail> </app>, qui <label type="structure">Obiectio 1</label> <app> <lem>impugnat</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Conclusio prima</witDetail> </app> <ref target="#snx020" type="source" n="20"/>conclusionem <app> <lem>illam</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">istam</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">scilicet primam in secundo folio post sextam opinionem</witDetail> </app> quam posui in principiis <app> <lem>meis</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">scilicet</witDetail> </app>: <app> <lem>theologia</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">est</witDetail> </app> non est scientia eo <app> <lem>modo</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">quod philosophi</witDetail> </app> quo philosophi <app> <lem>de</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>scientia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2 #Pr1">sint</rdg> </app> locuti<note xml:id="snx020" type="source" source="#b-ConrSoltau-Sent" subtype="cf" n="20">lib. 1, pr., q. 1, art. 2, p. 2, co. 1</note> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">de scientia</rdg> </app>. <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">quam</rdg> </app> Probavi <app> <lem>eam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> sic: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1</label> quia philosophi <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2 #W5">sint</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1">locuti</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>locuti</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sunt</rdg> </app> de scientia <app> <lem>quae</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">quam</rdg> </app> potest acquiri sine <app> <lem>fide</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">Christiana</witDetail> </app> Christianae religionis. Sed theologia sine <app> <lem>tali</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> fide <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">talis</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>acquiri</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> non potest, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1 #U1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Respondet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">respondit</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Responsio</witDetail> </app> magister <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">meus</rdg> </app> <label type="structure">Ob. 1.2</label> negando primam partem assumpti: nisi ego vellem loqui, <app> <lem>dicit</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app>, de speciebus scientiarum inventis per philosophos. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Contra</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Contra illa</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Contra</witDetail> </app>: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.2</label> <app> <lem>scientiarum</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">de quibus</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>principia</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">principaliter</rdg> </app> de quibus philosophi <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Ox2 #Pr1">sint</rdg> </app> locuti; <app> <lem>habent</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">habet</rdg> </app> ortum suae cognitionis <locus target="#Pr1" from="134ra"/> ex sensatis sine dono <app> <lem>Dei</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> spirituali superaddito. Igitur ipsi <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2 #U1 #W5">sunt</rdg> </app> locuti de scientia quae potest acquiri sine fide religionis Christianae. Consequentia <app> <lem>tenet</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">patet</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, cum fides sit donum ad credendum et <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">ad</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>cognoscendum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">cognoscendos</rdg> </app> articulos datum, ut omnes <app> <lem>sancti</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">doctores</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>doctores</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sancti</rdg> </app> dicunt. <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>assumptum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">antecedens</rdg> </app> patet quia ante omnia in scientiis de quibus philosophi <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1">locuti</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9 #U1">sunt</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>locuti</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1">sunt</rdg> </app> oportet praecognosci <app> <lem>de</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>subiecto</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> si est et quid est. Et hoc ex sensatis, quia propter <app> <lem>hoc</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> <app> <lem>dicit</lem> <rdg wit="#U1"/> </app> <ref target="#snx021" type="source" n="21"/>Philosophus <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">in</rdg> </app> primo Posteriorum in tractatu de ignorantia quod <app> <lem>carens</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Wo1">carent</rdg> </app> aliquo sensu non potest habere scientiam sensibilis <app> <lem>illius</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">istius</rdg> </app> sensus<note xml:id="snx021" type="source" source="#b-Arist-AnalPoster" subtype="cf" n="21">?????????</note>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Item</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item</witDetail> </app>, omnis <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Wo1">philosophi</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>scientia</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">scientiam</rdg> </app> de <app> <lem>qua</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">quavibus</rdg> </app> philosophi <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1">locuti</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9 #U1">sunt</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>locuti</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1">sunt</rdg> </app> et de qua <app> <lem>unquam</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1 #U1 #W5">umquam</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1">undique</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9">tum quam</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">de</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>intendebant</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1">intendebam</rdg> </app> sic se <app> <lem>habent</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">habet</rdg> </app>, quod <locus target="#T1" from="128rb"/> tam principia <app> <lem>ipsorum</lem><rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #Pr1 #Wo1">ipsarum</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9 #W5">eorum</rdg> </app> quam <app> <lem>etiam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> conclusiones clare cognoscuntur, sed in <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">Scriptura</rdg> </app> sacra <app> <lem>theologia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, ut dicit Apostolus, <locus target="#Ox2" from="109vb"/> “<ref target="#snx022" type="source" n="22"/>videmus <app> <lem>aliqua</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">autem hic</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">aliqua</witDetail> </app> per speculum et in <app> <lem>aenigmate</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="ac">auctoritate</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="mg"/> </app><note xml:id="snx022" type="source" source="#b-B-ICor" n="22">13, 12</note>”, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Secundo</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Secundo</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item</witDetail> </app> dicit magister <app> <lem>ille</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2 #U1">iste</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1">meus</rdg> </app> solvendo <ref target="#snx023" type="source" n="23"/><app> <lem>unum</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="mg"/> </app> de <app> <lem>meis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">argumentis</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>argumentis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">meis</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">scilicet id</witDetail> </app><note xml:id="snx023" type="source" source="#b-ConrSoltau-Sent" subtype="cf" n="23">lib. 2, pr., q. 1, art. 2, co. 1</note>, quod <label type="structure">Obiectio 2</label> non <app> <lem>oportet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> omnia <app> <lem>principia</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">principaliter</rdg> </app> scientiarum <app> <lem>vel</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">iam</rdg> </app> <locus target="#W5" from="94rb"/> esse nota per superiorem scientiam <app> <lem>vel</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">per</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>inductionem</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">inductione</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1"/> </app>. <app> <lem>Ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> dicit quod non oportet, quia <app> <lem>dicit</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">quod instantia</witDetail> </app> pro instantia quod sit principium <locus target="#K1" from="344a"/> in astronomia, quod <app> <lem>quilibet</lem> <witDetail wit="#Wo1" type="add.">orb.</witDetail> </app> orbis planetarum <app> <lem>habeant</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">habeat</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">habet</witDetail> </app> tres orbes <app> <lem>excentricos</lem><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Wo1">ecentricos</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2 #T1 #W5">et centricos</rdg> <rdg wit="#Pr1">ecemtricos</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">encentricos</rdg> </app> et <app> <lem>tamen</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> nec <locus target="#Ma1" from="154ra"/> per superiorem scientiam, nec per sensum <app> <lem>etc.</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #Pr1 #T1"/> </app> hoc <app> <lem>fit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sit</rdg> </app> manifestum. </p> <p> <locus target="#U1" from="129rb"/> <app> <lem>Contra</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Contra dicta</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Contra</witDetail> </app>: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2</label> per <app> <lem>experientias</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">experientia</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>compulsi</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">compulsii</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2 #Pr1">sint</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5"/> </app> philosophi ad salvandum <app> <lem>ea</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">eam</rdg> </app> quae <app> <lem>contingunt</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">contingit</rdg> </app> circa motus planetarum ad ponendum <app> <lem>talia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">talis</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#T1"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #T1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Consequenter</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item...</witDetail> </app> dicit <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">iste</rdg> </app> quod <label type="structure">Ob. 2.2</label> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">principium</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>istud</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Pr1">illud</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">vul.</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>vulgatum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fulgatum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>principium</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <locus target="#M9" from="100ra"/> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="del">vel</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>Philosophus</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">secundo Posteriorum</witDetail> </app> saepe <app> <lem>ponit</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">scilicet</witDetail> </app> quod <ref target="#snx024" type="source" n="24"/>principia scientiarum <app> <lem>fiunt</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">sint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>nota</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">memoria</witDetail> </app> sensu et experientia vel inductione<note xml:id="snx024" type="source" source="#b-X-AuctArist" subtype="cf" n="24">Metaph. III Comm., n. 96; Anal. Post. II, n. 125</note>. Dicit <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">hoc</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>hoc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> esse verum quoad inventorem, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">et</rdg> </app> non <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">autem</rdg> </app> quoad auditorem. </p> <p> Ecce applicemus hoc ad propositum de theologia, quam <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>vocat</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">vocant</rdg> </app> scientiam eo modo <app> <lem>sicut</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1">quo</rdg> </app> philosophi <app> <lem>de</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem>scientia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">locuti</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sunt</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>locuti</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Wo1">de</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Wo1">scientia</rdg> </app>: an eius principia sint <locus target="#Pr1" from="134rb"/> inventori sic nota. <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.2</label> Patet quod non, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">d.</witDetail> </app> nec Deo, nec alicui creaturae. <app> <lem>Item</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Confirmatio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item</witDetail> </app>, <app> <lem>Philosophus</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">dicit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>dicit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">Philosophus</rdg> </app> in primo Posteriorum quod <ref target="#snx025" type="source" n="25"/>ex principiis aliter quam per demonstrationem <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">nobis</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">nobis</witDetail> </app> notis<note xml:id="snx025" type="source" source="#b-Arist-AnalPoster" subtype="cf" n="25">lib. 1, cap. 2, 71b26-28</note> et refert hoc ad inductionem <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> <app> <lem>experientiam</lem> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="exp">fiunt</witDetail> </app>, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#W5">ergo</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#T1"/> </app>. Fiunt conclusiones notae et <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">hic</rdg> </app> non loquitur de illo qui scientiam invenit, sed de eo <app> <lem>qui</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">dicit</witDetail> </app> discit, et in rei veritate quoad hoc est idem de inventore sicut de quocumque discente, ut manifestum est, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>. </p> <p> Etiam <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> dicit quod <label type="structure">Ob. 2.3</label> <app> <lem>articulis</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2 #Pr1">articulos</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>loquatur</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">loquitur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>indefinite</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">indiffinite</rdg> </app> quod <app> <lem>principia</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">fiunt</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>fiunt</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sint</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9">principia</rdg> </app> nota, <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1 #T1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Contra</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Contra</witDetail> </app>: <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.3</label> <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> assumit hoc <app> <lem>ad</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">in</rdg> </app> demonstrandum, <locus target="#T1" from="128va"/> sed ex <app> <lem>indefinita</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">infinita</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">indefinitis</rdg> <rdg wit="#T1">indiffinita</rdg> </app> nihil <app> <lem>demonstrantur</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">demonstratur</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">dicitur</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">ex</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>primo</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">dicitur</witDetail> </app> Posteriorum: <ref target="#snx026" type="source" n="26"/>omnis demonstratio <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> ex universalibus<note xml:id="snx026" type="source" source="#b-Arist-AnalPoster" subtype="cf" n="26">lib. 1, cap. 8, 75b24-25</note> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">est</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Ox2 #T1 #Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #T1 #Wo1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ultimo</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item</witDetail> </app>, <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> quaesivit <label type="structure">Ob. 2.4</label> qualem scientiam <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">ego</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>dicerem</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">dicerent</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">ipsam</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>theologiam</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">eo</witDetail> </app>, ex quo non <app> <lem>esset</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">diceret</rdg> </app> scientia eo modo quo philosophi <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">locuti</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sint</lem><rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #U1 #Wo1">sunt</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1">loquuntur</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">locuti</rdg> </app> de <app> <lem>scientiis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9 #Ox2">scientia</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">sint</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>locuti</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #M9"/> </app>. </p> <p> Dixi et dico quod <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.4</label> volo eam vocare scientiam sicut Scriptura sacra vocat eam et sancti, scilicet scientiam sanctorum <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">scilicet</rdg> </app>, scientiam salutis <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">et</rdg> </app>, scientiam pietatis, <locus target="#Wo1" from="393va"/> scientiam fidei. </p> <p> Et <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> consequenter quaerit <label type="structure">Ob. 2.5</label> quare <app> <lem>velim</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> eam <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">volo</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>vocare</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="ac">scientiam</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>scientiam</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="ac">vocare</witDetail> </app>. </p> <p> <locus target="#Ox2" from="110ra"/> Dico <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> <label type="structure">Ad ob. 2.5</label> <app> <lem>ideo</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app>, quia <locus target="#K1" from="344b"/> procedit a revelatis et supernaturaliter <app> <lem>creditis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">traditis</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>ad</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>alia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2 #Pr1">scilicet</rdg> </app>: ad <app> <lem>fidem</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">salutem</rdg> </app>, pietatem et <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">ad</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>salutem</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">fidem</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>pertinentia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">per pertinentia</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">pertinentiam</rdg> </app>. </p> <p rend="Title"> < Replicatio III > </p> <p> <app> <lem>Demum</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">deinde</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1 #W5" type="mg">Contra baccalarium praedicatorum</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Materia alia</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Aliud</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>descendo</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">descendam</rdg> </app> ad materiam in qua reverendus baccalarius de Sancto Clemente dignatus est mecum conferre, <app> <lem>qui</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">quia</rdg> </app> in uno suorum articulorum <app> <lem>aliquid</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1">aliquod</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>tractavit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">tractabit</rdg> </app> de credere. Ideo <label type="structure">Obiectio 1</label> <app> <lem>posuit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ponit</rdg> </app> contra me <app> <lem>istam</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #M9 #Ox2">illam</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">me</witDetail> </app> conclusionem: <app> <lem>fides</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Alia conclusio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Conclusio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Wo1">est</rdg> </app> non <app> <lem>solum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">est</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">solum</rdg> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> subiective in intellectu, sed etiam in voluntate et affectu. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Oppositam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #Pr1">oppositum</rdg> </app> huius <app> <lem>ego</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">eo</rdg> </app> posui in primo meo principio <locus target="#W5" from="94va"/> <app> <lem>ubi</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">in conclusione quarta tertii articuli</witDetail> </app> dixi quod <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1</label> <ref target="#snx027" type="source" n="27"/>habitus fidei est <app> <lem>solum</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">in</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>subiective</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1"/> </app> intellectu et nullo modo subiective in voluntate<note xml:id="snx027" type="source" source="#b-ConrSoltau-Sent" subtype="cf" n="27">lib. 1, pr., q. 2, compar. 1, co. 4</note>, et <app> <lem>ita</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ideo</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>credo</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">adhuc hoc</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">esse</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> nunc fortius quam tunc. Et ideo conclusionem meam <locus target="#Pr1" from="134va"/> probo sic <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">scilicet</rdg> </app>: <app> <lem>fides</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Probatio conclusionis</witDetail> </app> <locus target="#U1" from="129va"/> est habitus cognitivus, igitur est in subiecto cognitivo, et igitur non in voluntate. Consequentia prima <app> <lem>nota</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">est</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">nota</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">et</rdg> </app>. <app> <lem>Assumptum</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="del">patet</witDetail> </app> est Apostoli, <app> <lem>qui</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>dicit</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2"/> </app> <locus target="#Ma1" from="154rb"/> et sanctorum qui dicunt quod <ref target="#snx028" type="source" n="28"/>per fidem videmus <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>via</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> quae clare videbimus in patria<note xml:id="snx028" type="source" source="#b-B-ICor" subtype="cf" n="28">13, 12</note>. <app> <lem>Et</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item</witDetail> </app> specialiter probo <app> <lem>tertiam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1">meam</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>meam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Wo1">conclusionem</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1">tertiam</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>conclusionem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">tertiam</rdg> <rdg wit="#Wo1">meam</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">eiusdem tertii articuli</witDetail> </app> quam etiam impugnat, scilicet quod fides non <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">simul</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>simul</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">est</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">et</rdg> </app> intellectu et voluntate, quia <app> <lem>si</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2"/> </app> <locus target="#T1" from="128vb"/> sic, posset pari ratione idem habitus fidei in numero <app> <lem>esse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">esset</rdg> </app> in intellectibus et <locus target="#M9" from="100rb"/> voluntatibus plurium <app> <lem>hominum</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">omnium</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>vel</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">et</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>omnium</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">unius</rdg> </app>, quod est manifeste falsum. <app> <lem>Secundo</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">secunda</rdg> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Secundo ad idem</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item secundo</witDetail> </app> sic: si fides est in <app> <lem>utraque</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">utroque</rdg> </app> illarum potentiarum vel convenit istis potentiis formaliter idem actus, vel conveniunt <app> <lem>eis</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ei</rdg> </app> diversi actus, secundum unum <app> <lem>tamen</lem> <witDetail wit="#Wo1" type="ac">tantum</witDetail> </app> habitum. Primum <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">dici</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>potest</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>dici</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> propter illud <app> <lem>vulgatum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">vulgare</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">fulgatum</rdg> </app> principium: <ref target="#snx029" type="source" n="29"/>potentiae distinguuntur per <app> <lem>actus</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">ut patet</witDetail> </app><note xml:id="snx029" type="source" source="#b-Arist-DeAn" subtype="cf" n="29">????????</note>, secundo et tertio De anima. <app> <lem>Nec</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> secundum <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">etiam</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>dici</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1">potest</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">non</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>potest</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1">dici</rdg> </app>, quia <app> <lem>ab</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> uno <app> <lem>simplici</lem> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="del">et</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>habitu</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">habitum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="iter"/> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">docebunt</witDetail> </app> procedunt <app> <lem>actus</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">habitus</rdg> </app> formaliter distincti, ut patet inductive, <locus target="#K1" from="345a"/> quia ab habitu aedificandi non procedunt diversi actus formaliter <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">distincti</rdg> </app>, sicut nec ab <app> <lem>habitu</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">actu</rdg> </app> citharizandi. Et <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">illa</rdg> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> est <ref target="#snx030" type="source" n="30"/>intentio Philosophi <app> <lem>secundo</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">secundi</rdg> </app> Ethicorum<note xml:id="snx030" type="source" source="#b-Arist-EthNic" subtype="cf" n="30">????????</note> per totum. <app> <lem>Tertio</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Tertio ad idem</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item tertio</witDetail> </app> sic: visio patriae non erit in voluntate, sed in intellectu, igitur <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Responsum</witDetail> </app> ibi respondet <app> <lem>iste</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">ille</rdg> </app> reverendus <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">magister</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">et</rdg> </app> baccalarius <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <label type="structure">Ob. 1.2</label> licet visio patriae <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">principaliter</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>principaliter</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">sit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1"/> </app> <app> <lem>intellectu</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">s.</witDetail> </app>, <locus target="#Ox2" from="110rb"/> tamen consecutive <app> <lem>est</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del. p.c."/> </app> in voluntate, quia dicit <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">quod</rdg> </app>: nemo potest Deum videre et non diligere. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Oppositum</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9 #Ox2" type="mg">Oppositum</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>istius</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1">illius</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.2</label> <app> <lem>assignat</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> pro causa <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">assignant</rdg> </app> multi sollemnes tenent. Et potest <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">probari</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>probari</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">sic</rdg> </app>: visio et <app> <lem>dilectio</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">delicio</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #U1 #Wo1">sunt</rdg> </app> actus realiter distincti, igitur non <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>contradictio</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1">contradico</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>hunc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2 #Pr1"/> </app> videre Deum et <app> <lem>non</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="supl"/> </app> diligere <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">Deum</rdg> </app>, maxime cum videre nullo modo dependeat <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">a</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>voluntate</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">dilectione</rdg> </app>, sed potius aliquo modo econverso. Consequentia <app> <lem>tenet</lem> <rdg wit="#W5"/> </app> per diffinitionem contradictionis in <ref target="#snx031" type="source" n="31"/>primo Perihermeneias<note xml:id="snx031" type="source" source="#b-Arist-DeInterpr" subtype="cf" n="31">????????</note>. <app> <lem>Sed</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">autem antecedens</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>assumptum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">antecedens</rdg> </app> est <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">notum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>de</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">per</rdg> </app> se <locus target="#Pr1" from="134vb"/> <app> <lem>manifestum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Hic</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">hinc</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Item responso</witDetail> </app> dico quod <label type="structure">Ad ob. 1.2.2</label> <app> <lem>mihi</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">videtur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>videtur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">mihi</rdg> </app> quod in solutione <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>concedat</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">concedit</rdg> </app> quod fides sit principaliter in intellectu, sed consecutive in voluntate. Si hoc intelligit quod <app> <lem>migret</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">migraret</rdg> </app> de intellectu ad voluntatem, hoc non video. <app> <lem>Si</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">autem</witDetail> </app> intelligit quod actus voluntatis sequatur <locus target="#T1" from="129ra"/> visionem, ex hoc non sequitur quod visio sit in voluntate, igitur <app> <lem>assumptum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Ox2">argumentum</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5"/> </app> <app> <lem>adhuc</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">ad</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#T1">hoc</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>stat</lem> <rdg wit="#Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#W5">assumptum</rdg> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Solutio</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Responsio in ali.</witDetail> </app> argumenta sua <app> <lem>nunc</lem> <rdg wit="#U1">non</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> venio. <locus target="#U1" from="129vb"/> Ad primum quando <app> <lem>arguit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">sic</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">arguit</rdg> </app>: <label type="structure">Arg. 1</label> actus <locus target="#W5" from="94vb"/> ex <app> <lem>habitu</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">habita</rdg> </app> fidei elicitus procedit <app> <lem>tam</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">ut</witDetail> </app> a voluntate quam ab intellectu. <label type="structure">Ad arg. 1</label> Concedo illam, non tamen propter suam probationem quae est <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">illa</rdg> </app>: <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">quod</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>utraque</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">utrique</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>istarum</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">illarum</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1">illorum</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> potentiarum nata est per habitum perfici, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>dico</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>utraque</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>nata</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>perfici</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>per</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>fidem</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app>, <app> <lem>sed</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>sola</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2"/> </app> <app> <lem>intellectiva</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>potentia</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem>nata</lem> <rdg wit="#M9"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">perfici</rdg> </app> per fidem <app> <lem>perfici</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #M9"/> </app>, et voluntas nullo modo perfici habet per fidem. </p> <p> Et cum infert quod <label type="structure">Arg. 1.2</label> <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #Wo1">ergo</rdg> </app> habitus fidei non tantum est in intellectu <locus target="#Wo1" from="393vb"/> subiective, sed <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">etiam</rdg> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="supl"/> </app> in voluntate seu affectu, <label type="structure">Ad arg. 1.2</label> nego illam <locus target="#Ma1" from="154va"/> consequentiam. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Et</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Probatio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> </app> probat consequentiam <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>: <label type="structure">Arg. 1.3</label> quia talis actus procedit ab intellectu, <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#W5">est</rdg> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="supl"/> </app> imperio voluntatis, <app> <lem>videlicet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>secundum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>movetur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>a</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>voluntate</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ad</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>assentiendum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">a</rdg> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">voluntate</rdg> </app>, <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>oportet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>huiusmodi</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>habitus</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>tam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">a</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>voluntate</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>quam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>intellectu</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>si</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>debet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>esse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>habitus</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <locus target="#Ox2" from="110va"/> <app> <lem>fidei</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>perfectus</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="pc"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Dico</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ego</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Responsio</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>ego</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">dico</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <label type="structure">Ad arg. 1.3</label> <app> <lem>hoc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>oportet</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app>. <app> <lem>Immo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>dico</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>istud</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #T1">illud</rdg> <rdg wit="#M9">hoc</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <locus target="#M9" from="100va"/> <app> <lem>argumentum</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #T1">assumptum</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>contra</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>me</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>recte</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>evidenter</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>probat</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>suam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sed</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>meam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>conclusionem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Probatio conclusionis</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>optime</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sequitur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>iste</lem> <rdg wit="#M9 #Ox2">ille</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>actus</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>procedit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ab</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>intellectu</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>imperio</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>voluntatis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app>; <app> <lem>igitur</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">ergo</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="supl"/> </app>, nec <app> <lem>ipse</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">ille</rdg> <rdg wit="#Ox2">iste</rdg> </app> actus, nec <app> <lem>eius</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">huiusmodi</rdg> </app> habitus est in voluntate. Patet consequentia, quia voluntas non habet imperium super suos actus quos elicit, sed super actus aliarum <locus target="#K1" from="345b"/> potentiarum, quibus <app> <lem>imperat</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">intrat</rdg> <rdg wit="#U1">inferat</rdg> </app>. Etiam si argumentum valeret, probaretur consimili <app> <lem>modo</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="del">quod omnia</witDetail> </app> per omnia, quod geometria esset subiective in voluntate, quia geometria est habitus, cuius actus est considerare circa magnitudines, qui inquam actus saepe fit ex imperio voluntatis. <locus target="#T1" from="129rb"/> <app> <lem>Immo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">igitur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>secundum</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">argumentum</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>fundamentum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">fundamenta</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>istius</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9 #Ox2">illius</rdg> </app> argumenti omnes artes et omnes practicae <app> <lem>scientiae</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">esset</witDetail> </app> essent <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ox2">simul</rdg> </app> subiective in voluntate <app> <lem>simul</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2"/> </app> et in intellectu, quia <app> <lem>aedificator</lem> <rdg wit="#T1">aedificatur</rdg> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="ac">aedificatur</witDetail> </app> voluntarie aedificat, et moralis philosophus <app> <lem>voluntarie</lem> <rdg wit="#W5">voluntate</rdg> </app> <locus target="#Pr1" from="135ra"/> de felicitate considerat, <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1">et</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>logicus</lem> <rdg wit="#M9">logica</rdg> </app> voluntarie syllogizat <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Ma1">igitur etc</rdg> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Ad secundum argumentum</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Ad secundum</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>secundum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">argumentum</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>argumentum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">secundum</rdg> </app> quo <app> <lem>arguit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">arguitur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>sic</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #W5"/> </app>: <label type="structure">Arg. 2</label> si fides non est subiective in voluntate, vel <app> <lem>ista</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #M9">illa</rdg> </app> est fides informis, <app> <lem>vel</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="supl"/> </app> <app> <lem>fides</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> formata. Non informis, quia <app> <lem>illa</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ista</rdg> </app> non meretur <app> <lem>habere</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">hoc</rdg> </app> nomen fidei; nec formata, quia voluntas est subiectum caritatis. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Dico</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Solutio</witDetail> </app> <locus target="#U1" from="130ra"/> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <label type="structure">Ad arg. 2</label> sive sit <app> <lem>fides</lem> <rdg wit="#W5"/> </app> informis, <app> <lem>sive</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">vel</rdg> </app> formata, non habet aliud subiectum quam intellectum. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> ad <app> <lem>replicationes</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">replicationem</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>dico</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">as.</witDetail> </app>: ad primam, quod <label type="structure">Ad repl. 1</label> fides <app> <lem>informis</lem> <witDetail wit="#K1" type="mg"/> <witDetail wit="#Ma1" type="del">n.</witDetail> </app> est in intellectu <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>meretur</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>dici</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>fides</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>iuxta</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>illud</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>apostoli</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #T1"/> </app> <app> <lem>prima</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1 #T1 #Wo1">primo</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>Corinthios</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>tertiodecimo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>: “<ref target="#snx032" type="source" n="32"/><app> <lem>si</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>habuero</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>omnem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>fidem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">ut</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>ita</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ut</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>montes</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">sic</rdg> </app> <locus target="#W5" from="95ra"/> <app> <lem>transferam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>caritatem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>autem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">habit</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>habeam</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">habuero</rdg> <rdg wit="#W5">habeo</rdg> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">vel est</witDetail> </app><note xml:id="snx032" type="source" source="#b-B-ICor" subtype="cf" n="32">13, 2</note>” <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">igitur</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #U1 #W5"/> </app>. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Ad secundum</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem>secundam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>replicationem</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <label type="structure">Ad repl. 2</label> <app> <lem>concedo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>voluntas</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>subiectum</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>caritatis</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>et</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>nego</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>consequentiam</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>quod</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>ergo</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>fides</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>formata</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1"/> </app> <app> <lem>non</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>sit</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>intellectu</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app>, <app> <lem>quia</lem> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="iter"/> </app> <app> <lem>dico</lem> <witDetail wit="#W5" type="iter"/> </app> quod fides tunc est et <app> <lem>dicitur</lem> <witDetail wit="#Wo1" type="del">in</witDetail> </app> formata in intellectu, quando caritas <app> <lem>est</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Pr1"/> </app> <app> <lem>in</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="del">intellectu</witDetail> </app> voluntate. </p> <p> Ad confirmationem suam <label type="structure">Confirm.</label> <app> <lem>pro</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">dico</rdg> </app> qua <app> <lem>adducit</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ducit</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>beatum</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1"/> </app> Augustinum qui, in libro De praedestinatione sanctorum, dicit quod <ref target="#snx033" type="source" n="33"/>fides <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem>credentium</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="supl">in</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">in</rdg> </app> voluntate consistit<note xml:id="snx033" type="source" source="#b-Aug-DePraedestSanct" subtype="cf" n="33">n. 5/10</note>, dico quod <label type="structure">Ad confirm.</label> <app> <lem>ille</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">ipse</rdg> </app> non intendit quod habitus fidei sit subiective in voluntate, sed quod <app> <lem>actus</lem> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">pro</witDetail> </app> procedit imperative a <app> <lem>voluntate</lem> <witDetail wit="#Pr1" type="del">bene habent</witDetail> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#K1">bene habet scilicet habitus</rdg> </app>. Et <app> <lem>ex</lem> <rdg wit="#Ox2">per</rdg> </app> hoc <locus target="#Ox2" from="110vb"/> habentur quod habitus fidei non est in voluntate, <locus target="#Ma1" from="154vb"/> quia actus <app> <lem>eliciti</lem> <rdg wit="#Wo1">elici</rdg> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="ac">elicitus</witDetail> </app> a voluntate bene habent suos habitus, secundum quos eliciuntur <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">a</rdg> </app> voluntate, sicut diligere. Sed actus <locus target="#T1" from="129va"/> imperati nullo modo <app> <lem>habent</lem> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="del">h.</witDetail> </app> habitus <app> <lem>suos</lem> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="supl"/> </app> in voluntate, <app> <lem>quando</lem> <rdg wit="#Ma1">quia</rdg> </app> non eliciuntur a voluntate, sed <app> <lem>imperantur</lem> <witDetail wit="#T1" type="mg">sed imperantur</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">ex</witDetail> </app>, <app> <lem>etc</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ma1 #Ox2 #U1 #Wo1"/> </app>. <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#M9">et</rdg> <witDetail wit="#U1" type="del">et</witDetail> </app> Haec <app> <lem>sint</lem> <rdg wit="#K1 #Ox2">sunt</rdg> </app> dicta cum reverentia. </p> <p> <app> <lem>Ad</lem> <witDetail wit="#M9" type="mg">Ad argumentum</witDetail> <witDetail wit="#Ox2" type="mg">Argumentum</witDetail> </app> argumentum <app> <lem>in</lem> <rdg wit="#K1">principale</rdg> </app> <app> <lem>contrarium</lem> <rdg wit="#K1"/> </app> <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#W5">conclusionis</rdg> </app>, <label type="structure">Ad arg. contra.</label> responsum est in positione <app> <lem/><rdg wit="#Pr1">etc</rdg> </app>. </p> </body> </text> </TEI>
×
...
...